Precedent and prior-advice search across 19 years of matter files
Their document management system had everything and surfaced nothing — search worked on filenames and metadata, so finding a prior position on an issue meant asking whoever had been there longest.
We indexed matter files, advice memos and counsel opinions, with access permissions mirroring their existing matter-level restrictions exactly. First measured pass was 74%; most failures were documents with no useful text layer. Running OCR across the pre-2015 archive took it to 94%.
The unexpected benefit was for the junior end. A first-year can now find how we argued something in 2019 without needing to know that we did. — Helena Marsh, Managing Partner
What didn't work: we tried extending it to draft first-pass advice notes. Partners rewrote all of them and we withdrew it after five weeks. Retrieval yes, drafting no.